@lovethynerd
Love Thy Nerd
Love Nerds + Engage Culture + Build Community

Watching Your Child Develop Their Own Fandom

When our youngest daughter was two she got her much loved baby. We have an adorable video of her opening up this carefully wrapped Christmas present as she whispers “my baby” upon seeing what’s actually inside of the colorful paper. This baby she took with her everywhere; to church, grocery shopping, road trips, nap times, you name it this baby was with her. This particular baby was her baby, her oh so precious baby. 

It was a plush Gollum. 

You read that correctly, her baby was Gollum. Yearly, or almost yearly, we watch all three Lord of the Rings movies (extended edition of course), in one day with food and themed games sprinkled about. Though I did not have my two year old watch the movies with us, I’m not that uncaring, she did happen to be in the room when Gollum was first shown and exclaimed upon seeing that creature “baby-my baby!” This carried on for a bit, she got the plush for Christmas, and later a fleece blanket, which is still on her bed to this day. 

Our youngest became enamored with this character for one reason and one reason only, because my husband and I are major Lord of the Rings fans. Exposure is what brought our daughter to that point at such a young age. Did she genuinely have affection for Gollum? Of course she did, but that affection had us as the jumping off point. 

As parents, we should always have influence over a child’s activities, especially when they’re as young as two. There is joy and excitement in geeking out over the same things. Enjoying the same stuff together. And, frankly, curating and screening our children’s entertainment. However, there comes a time when your kid starts to develop tastes outside of yours and if you sit back and watch them flourish, with godly guardrails, and maybe even try to join along, it is just as fun as watching a two year old call a plush Gollum baby. 

Our soon to be twelve year old has been going down a few different paths all by herself, and it has been a delight to see. 

 

Her first foray into a fandom that was not spurred by her father or I is the book series: Keeper of the Lost Cities. This is an ongoing book series written by Shannon Messenger following Sophie Foster as she discovers she’s not a human but an elf that was hidden in the human realm. And thus chaos ensues. There are eleven books published, most with well over 400 pages, and a graphic novel, which our youngest is reading. I can almost guarantee that if you have an avid reader who is between 9-14 they have read this series. They have gawked over this series. They have created a playlist on YouTube based on fanwork of this series. Ok, maybe that last one your child hasn’t done. 

It has been fascinating to watch our eldest see this world that none of the adults in her life even knew about. And I mean none. I work at a public library, and none of the libraries even had these books in their system just two years ago, even though the first book had been published in 2012. And my library, like many around the country, was a part of a consortium, and none of them owned these books. Yet, all of my eldest classmates have read the books, and those who owned these books let others in class read them. By the end of the school year last year every single child in my daughter’s class had read all the published books.

And not just read them.

These tweens have teams, theories, and arguments over this series. At my daughter’s birthday party with her classmates one of the boys put in her card “Just for your birthday, Keefe is better than Fitz-but I won’t admit to this tomorrow!”

What does that even mean? Who are Keefe and Fitz? Is this a Jacob/Edward thing all over again? Is this Peeta/Gale? Is this the current generation of tweens love triangle that they’ll fight and obsess over for years to come? But watching her grow in this world doesn’t stop there. 

If any of you out there have daughters you probably know they really enjoy making jewelry. And now many of the pieces she makes have to do with this fandom. On one of her bracelets there was the word ‘Moonlark’ and the color brown was prominent. She was shocked, SHOCKED, when I didn’t understand it was because Sophie is the only elf with brown eyes and the Black Swan’s codename for her is ‘Moonlark.’ How dare I, her mother, not know every single little thing about the novels? And how dare you, reader, not know what the Black Swan is? 

 

There’s more of course. I get to watch my child read these books. I see her sit in the living room squirming and wriggling about. She yells random things at random people, and giggles about things that honestly make her look a bit…um….unhinged. And yet, I love it. Here her generation has something that they love and they get to share with others, and they, too, get to be severely disappointed by a screen adaptation. Their time will come for that disappointment, as it has come for all of us.  

Solely because of the popularity of these books my library, and others in our consortium, have since purchased this entire series. Who knew the tweens could make that happen? And they circulate a lot. The entire series is never on the shelf all at once. This is a series the kids have made happen, and many adults didn’t even know about. 

My eldest was so obsessed with KotLC (as the cool kids refer to it) that when it was my turn to pick a book for my book club, I picked the first one in this series. I just needed to have a baseline of what my kid was talking about all the time. Shocker, we all really enjoyed it and have continued reading the series separately outside of the book club. How cool is that? My daughter found a series that I, even working at a public library, knew nothing about, and she brought it to me and my friends and now we get to enjoy the series she put in front of us! 

Something unexpected, yet amazing, about watching your children develop their own fandom- they now get to share something with you! Something new, something different, something you haven’t discovered. And I, for one, am here for the journey. 

But don’t take it just from me. Start your own journey, watch your children as they start to grow in their tastes apart from you. Heck, join them in their fandoms, even if they make no sense. Maybe even especially if they make no sense. Their early years were completely determined by us; what they watched, what we read to them, even the music they listened to. Now it’s our turn for them to take us on their adventures. 





Bethany has been writing since the first grade, and is still quite passionate about the written word. As she’s grown older, her interests have swerved into board games, where she and her husband host a review channel, and raising her two daughters. Now Bethany is being drawn back into writing, consistently blending all of her interests together. She can be found reading, playing a board game, or enjoying the outdoors. She currently resides in Iowa with her husband and two daughters.

Reader Comments

Related Content

The Scarlet Witch, Hannah, and the Direction of Our Grief

Scarlet Witch’s story reveals the dangers of unresolved grief. Explore how Wanda and Hannah offer contrasting responses to motherhood, loss, and faith.

Why Diversity is Good and How Rings of Power Did It Wrong

Rings of Power diversity choices sparked debate, but Tolkien’s detailed Middle-earth needed deeper worldbuilding to make inclusive casting feel coherent.

What Fan Hatred of Rings of Power Teaches Us about the Bible

The Rings of Power criticism reveals a deeper point about biblical inerrancy, adaptation, and why faithfulness to source material is not the only measure of art.

Bible Thump 171 | NextGen Nerd: Fleeing from Fear

CJ Burroughs (NextGen Nerd) shares a personal parenting story revealing how fear can deceive us—and how faith in Christ restores peace and victory.

In Defense of the Good Guy

A heartfelt reflection on why children need strong, virtuous heroes in the stories they love. From a little girl rooting for villains to discovering the noble characters of Narnia, this piece explores the lasting impact of good-guy role models in shaping young hearts and imaginations.

GCN 2 | Sean Sutton: Building the Bible Brick by Brick

Radio Matt talks with Sean Sutton of Bible Bricks about their 1000%+ funded Kickstarter and how it’s changing how kids learn the Bible.

The King of Kings Early Review

Church Nerds 90 | The Super-Peer

The Church Nerds take a look at how media is influencing adolescents today compared to when they were children. Parenting, screen time, content limits, and more are on the table today on the show.