Love Thy Nerd
Love Nerds + Engage Culture + Build Community

Finding Forgiveness in Silent Hill 2

“Don’t I love her? When I am near her I am nearer things which are near her.”
-André Breton

Regret isn’t a simple emotion. It’s more an amalgam of many different feelings bundled into one thing that we name “regret”. It’s sadness, it’s anger, it’s fear of our past failings manifesting themselves in the present. It’s self-loathing. Really, it’s the inverse of nostalgia. Instead of looking fondly at the past for comfort, one looks back in disgust because of actions already taken. Whether or not things are your fault is inconsequential—you now have to live with the consequences of what led you here.

I’ve often said that I’ve never regretted anything in my life. Even the bad times I look back upon as a season for learning and growth. But that’s not necessarily true. For two years, regret ate at me like a cancer while depression enveloped my wife.

In 2016, my mother-in-law began exhibiting symptoms of what we would later find out in December to be the first signs of ALS. My wife was devastated. Not only did she have to deal with the slow loss of her mother to an awful disease, she had to do this 2,500 miles away from home since Lynn still lived in Kentucky and we had moved to Washington state for my new job.

After Lynn’s death, we moved her father up here to be with us. But David passed away over a year after that, due to complications from dementia. My wife again grieved and regret still lingered. I was ashamed that I couldn’t do more—that we continued the downward spiral into grief and regret.

In Silent Hill 2, we begin with the appearance of James Sutherland. Years earlier, he had lost his wife, Mary, to illness—only to receive a letter asking him to return to Silent Hill and meet her “in our special place.” Unsure of her meaning, James heads to the center of town, Rosewater Park, where he meets Maria.

James’ guilt over his feelings towards Mary and her illness put my own into perspective.

Maria is the yang to Mary’s yin. She is everything that James’ animal instincts wanted from his bedridden wife and the nurses who attended her: forward, flirtatious, and in touch with her sexuality. She decides to help him find Mary, following him into the nearby hospital. There, Pyramid Head stalks and kills Maria-the first time of many. Maria soon reappears healthy and whole with no memory of her death, only to be killed again and again. Eventually arriving at his and Mary’s “special place”, the Lake View Hotel, James plays a video tape that reveals he killed his wife in the final days of her illness.

James’ guilt over his feelings towards Mary and her illness put my own into perspective. I was often frustrated. And I wasn’t always sure where to aim this frustration. Sometimes I was upset at not being able to fix everything that was upsetting my wife. I had to help her endure it even though that too was causing me pain. It was inconvenient. I was tired. Right before the final boss, James recalls a moment where he brought flowers home to Mary, who lashed out at him for the gesture. James leaves Mary in tears as she begs for him to come back and tell her everything is going to be OK. Did I abandon my wife during times when she needed me the most? Did leaving her to sleep in order to go read, or write, or play a game count as dereliction of my duty as a husband?

Silent Hill 2 helped me to face my feelings of regret head on by showing me that there are circumstances that are beyond my control. Sometimes the only thing we can do is learn to forgive ourselves. As James had to go through his own personal hell to seek redemption, I also spent a long, long time contemplating and being tormented by events I could not see coming. There is an escape. But without forgiveness, from and for ourselves and others, we live in our own little Silent Hills.

Daniel Motley is a product manager and freelance writer living in Washington state. He has contributed to a number of outlets, including the Art of Manliness, The Gospel Coalition, and Christ and Pop Culture.

Reader Comments

Related Content

Super Retro Bros 2 | X-Men ’97 is Magnetic

Bubba & Matt discuss how Disney has pulled off the near impossible - relaunching a show that originally ended 17 years ago in a way that is both nostalgic and fresh. (Spoilers ahead, so be warned.)

Super Retro Bros 1 | Smells Like Nostalgia (Pilot)

Matt & Bubba welcome you to their nostalgic journey in this pilot episode of "Super Retro Bros." Today on the show, they seek to smell like the Nintendo 64 games they know and love.

Faith & Fandom 10 | Timothy G. Huguenin: Hillbilly Author of the Strange and Spooky

Timothy G. Huguenin is a hillbilly writer of the strange and spooky, living in the dark Allegheny Mountains of West Virginia. He is the author of the books Little One, When the Watcher Shakes, and Unknowing, I Sink. His short stories have appeared in various publications including Vastarien, Cosmic Horror Monthly, and The Saturday Evening Post.

4 Strangely Wholesome Scary Movies

Gwen Leong shares a set of scary movies that have a good heart, a family message, and/or a wholesome moral lesson - a great place to start for people leery of the genre.

Halloween & Horror | The Complete LTN Resource List

In the paradoxical dance between the sacred and the sinister, Halloween and horror content provides a unique opportunity for Christians to find allegorical significance that speaks to their beliefs and the human condition itself. Here is a collections of articles and podcasts that discuss this topic and more.

Redeeming Halloween: The Love of Jesus & Full-Size Candy Bars

Today in Nerd History | September 8

A daily re-cap of this date in the history of movies, TV shows, video games, comics, wrestling and more!

Facing the Past in Obi-Wan Kenobi – Episode 5

Steve Cullum writes about how the past haunts everyone in the Obi-Wan Kenobi series, and how there are right and wrong ways to respond to it.